12/02/13 - Havana Times - Cuba and the Dominican Left
Denationalization and Moral Hemiplegia
Haroldo Dilla Alfonso*
Doorway of the Old Wall of Havana. Photo: Juan Suarez
HAVANA TIMES - The Dominican Republic's Constitutional Court's recent
xenophobic and discriminatory decision of depriving thousands of
Haitian-born immigrants of their Dominican nationality had a collateral
upside to it: that of gathering the most valuable members of Dominican
society - intellectuals, activists and common citizens - in a single
Bravely, these individuals and organizations have publicly condemned the
ultra-nationalist sectors of the country's most reactionary Right and have
confronted the fascist-like threats (including calls for their death and
ostracism) with the utmost dignity.
All of this is admirable. I must confess, however, that when I look upon my
other condition, my Cuban nationality, I feel profound sadness, and this
because the majority of these individuals - not unlike the majority within
the democratic and Left end of the political spectrum in the DR - has never
stopped to consider that the reprehensible denationalization planned by the
Dominican government is child's play compared to the massive expropriation
of citizen rights that the Cuban government has practiced with its émigrés
Over one million Cubans have left their country over the last fifty years.
Their departures have been traumatic, many a time involving reprisals from
aggressive mobs, the loss of jobs, the expropriation of their modest
personal belongings and the rifting-apart of families.
These people have lost their right to reside on the island, to own property
there and even to visit the country freely. Thousands of Cubans have been
denied the right to visit the place of their birth, even when faced with
tragic family circumstances, such that many parents and sons and daughters
have had no other option than to imagine their final goodbyes in the
Cuban émigrés pay the most expensive consular services in the world, fees
which, in conjunction with the remittances which allow many Cubans to get
by, are an important source of revenue for Cuba's governing bureaucracy.
Even the island's recent migratory reforms leave intact the line of
separation between the nation and its émigrés, that is to say, between that
part of Cuba's population residing on the island and the other, one of the
most successful diasporas in the world.
Cuban émigrés continue to be deprived of their citizenship rights in the
country of their birth and continue to depend on government authorization
to be able to visit Cuba.
There is, of course, a difference between expropriated Dominicans and
Cubans who are divested of their rights. The former, for the most part
poor, remain imprisoned within the half-island. Cubans, who are generally
more qualified, enter a new society with an advantageous position and in
one way or another manage to succeed.
In the United States, they enjoy legal benefits thanks to a law that favors
them. I would say, however, that these are merely circumstantial
differences which are insignificant against the backdrop of the monstrous
way in which citizens are deprived of their rights and denaturalized. In
this sense, the crime perpetrated by the two governments is equally
perverse and, as such, equally reprehensible.
The reasons behind the moral hemiplegia of those who condemn one practice
and support - or simply remain silent about the other - is to be found in
In some cases, we are dealing with shameless and opportunistic complicity,
the complicity of those who wish to be associated with the Left simply
because that secures them benefits they would be unable to have elsewhere,
either for lack of talent or because of sheer idleness.
Tiny political factions allied to the government, foundations that depend
on public funds or splinter left-wing organizations that continue to thrive
within State structures are eloquent examples of this unredeemable segment
of the Dominican Republic's political fauna. They are beyond hope: the
swamps of politics are their natural habitat.
In other cases, we are witness to a sympathetic kind of complicity which
seeks nothing other than spiritual tranquility and co-existence with a
nostalgic discourse which speaks of a revolution and an anti-imperialist
resistance on which they may have once laid their hopes.
When they hear talk of Cuba, they cross their fingers, but, in fact, they
have never seriously considered the idea of living under the regime they
tolerate - and even praise - from a distance.
Curiously enough, they would also never have been willing to tolerate what
takes place in Cuba in their own country.
Putting aside the issue of émigrés for the moment, when I saw the obscene
nationalist rally organized in Parque Independencia on Dominican
television, I could not avoid noticing its similarity to the type of
aggression that Cuban dissidents suffer every day at the hands of
government-spurred mobs, whose methods and harangues are as fascist as the
ones I heard that Monday and who, in addition, can use physical violence
against their adversaries with impunity. And they do.
It is thus comprehensible that, in the words of Minister Gustavo Montalvo,
spoken during a visit to Havana, Cuban leaders "showed understanding
towards the position exposed by the Dominican government." It couldn't be
any other way.
The confluence of sympathy and opportunism has opened the doors of
Dominican academic and political spaces to detestable figures who have been
responsible for shameful acts of repression and coercion aimed at Cuban
I believe the personalities and organizations of the Dominican Republic's
democratic and progressive movement are faced with a challenge: putting
behind their nostalgia and moral paralysis and looking at Cuba through the
same democratic and humanistic lens which has allowed them to hold the
dignity of the Dominican Republic so high.
Cuban society certainly deserves this. -- (*) Haroldo Dilla is a Cuban
sociologist and historian living in the Dominican Republic.
Original Source / Fuente Original: http://www.havanatimes.org/?p=100393
CUBA-L FAIR USE NOTICE
This server contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of Cuba's political, economic, human rights, international, cultural, educational, scientific, sports and historical issues, among others. We distribute the materials on the basis of a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107. The material is distributed without profit. The material should be used for information, research and educational purposes. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/ uscode/17/107.shtml.